Tormented Souls 2 Horseman Puzzle Guide: Sword Positions and Marble Sword Location

Why the Tormented Souls 2 Horseman Puzzle Trips Everyone Up

The Tormented Souls 2 horseman puzzle stalls a lot of players in the Cemetery, mostly because the game never tells you that a missing arm is the real lock. Four statues — Victory, War, Death, and Famine — stand in the lower Burial Chamber, each holding a sword you can rotate, but until you push the Marble Sword into Death's empty shoulder, nothing you do matters. This guide walks the whole chain: how to reach the Tormented Souls 2 horseman puzzle, where the sword hides, and the exact clock angles that make the lift rise.

It's a short puzzle once the setup is done. The hard part is the prerequisite chain, which stretches back through the Cemetery Grounds statue, a metal detector hunt, and a dark run through the Catacombs. Get those out of the way and the horsemen take about two minutes.

Where the Tormented Souls 2 Horseman Puzzle Is Located

The statues sit on the lower floor of the Cemetery – Burial Chamber, and you reach them by climbing down the ladder in the main room. Getting into the Burial Chamber itself is easy: from the Cemetery Office safe zone, take the bunker door on the left side of the building.

Two things are worth grabbing before you touch a single sword:

• The hint. On the upper balcony, between the two angel statues, there's a book on a pedestal — the same spot where the Constellation Disk Piece sits on the railing. That book tells you how the swords should point. Screenshot it or read it twice.
• Your bearings. The balcony circles the chamber, so you can look down at all four statues before committing to anything.

The statues are easy to tell apart. Victory wears a crown, War wears a soldier's helmet, Death is a skeleton, and Famine is the gaunt figure with the sunken frame. Death is also the one with the missing arm — that's your first clue that the Tormented Souls 2 horseman puzzle has a fetch quest attached.

Before You Rotate Anything: Get the Marble Sword

You cannot finish this puzzle on rotation alone. The Marble Sword lives in the Catacombs, and the Catacombs only open after the Cemetery Grounds statue puzzle.

Here's the condensed path:

1. Complete the Constellation Disk. Combine the outer piece from the Old Mausoleum with the center piece from the Burial Chamber balcony, then rotate the rings (outer 5, middle 2, center 7) to match the Gemini plaque. Slot it into the two-children statue near the hanging tree to open the Gemini Mausoleum.
2. Pick up the Metal Detector inside the Gemini Mausoleum locker, along with the Morbid Illustrations note.
3. Sweep for three Octagons — Bronze near the hanging tree, Silver near the bridge by the West Cemetery gate, Gold behind the locked mausoleum in the West Cemetery.
4. Solve the PEDRO grave. Insert Gold, Silver, then Bronze, and rotate the dials to spell PEDRO. A panel opens behind the central statue, leading into the Catacomb.

Inside the Catacomb, light the candelabras with your Lighter, take the right fork for the Old Photo if you want it, then follow the main passage. You'll unlock a shortcut door back to the Burial Chamber, climb a set of stairs, and find a broken coffin in a dark chamber. The Marble Sword is inside — click it to collect it.

Heads up: picking up the sword spawns a barrier on the door behind you and drops a wave of zombies. Clear them, then take the shortcut back to the Burial Chamber. Some guides call this item the "Famine Sword," but the inventory name is the Marble Sword, and it belongs to the Death statue, not Famine.

Tormented Souls 2 Horseman Puzzle Solution: Sword Clock Positions

Each statue has a panel in front of it that rotates the sword in the figure's hand. Treat each sword as a clock hand and match the table below.

Victory is already set correctly, so leave that panel alone. Insert the Marble Sword into Death's shoulder first, then bring the other three into line. When all four match, a lift rises from the floor of the chamber — that's your confirmation that the Tormented Souls 2 horseman puzzle is solved.

One guide, PowerPyx, lists the solution as click counts instead: leave the crowned horseman untouched, rotate the armored one six times right, the decayed one three times right, and the repaired one once left. Those numbers assume every sword is still sitting at its default starting angle. If you've already been fiddling with the panels, trust the clock positions — they're the stable reference.

Step-by-Step Walkthrough

If you want the cleanest possible run, do it in this order:

1. Read the hint book on the balcony.
2. Climb down the ladder to the statue floor.
3. Open your inventory, select the Marble Sword, and use it on Death's missing arm.
4. Ignore the Victory panel entirely.
5. Rotate War until the blade points straight down — 6 o'clock.
6. Rotate Death until the blade points up and slightly left — 11 o'clock.
7. Rotate Famine until the blade points right — 3 o'clock.
8. Wait for the lift, then interact with it.

Examining each panel tells you which statue you're holding, so there's no risk of mixing up War and Famine if you approach from an odd angle.

What You Get After Solving the Tormented Souls 2 Horseman Puzzle

The lift carries you down into a new area and immediately triggers a cutscene. When it ends, you're standing in the Mass Grave (Other Side) — bloodied corpses, tentacles on the walls, the works — and Dr. Hertz shows up as the Cemetery's boss.

The fight has one rule: shooting Hertz directly does almost nothing, because bullets bounce off him. Kill his summoned zombies instead. Each time the room is cleared he drops onto his back, stunned, and that's your damage window. Repeat until he goes down, then use the mirror that opens up to reach the real-world Mass Grave.

Past the boss, the corridor rewards you with the Detachable Flashlight — a genuine upgrade, since you can fire weapons while it's on. It arrives empty, so pull the batteries out of the Cassette Player you picked up earlier and install them. Break the crates near the ladder to get back up to the Burial Chamber, and from there you can backtrack toward the Sewer Walkway and the Sledgehammer.

If you're playing on PC and want to check patch notes or system requirements, the official Tormented Souls 2 Steam page is the place to look.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the order I rotate the horsemen matter? No. Only the final sword angles count, so you can set Famine before War or fix Death last. The one thing that does matter is inserting the Marble Sword before you expect the Tormented Souls 2 horseman puzzle to complete.

Where exactly is the Marble Sword? In the Catacombs, inside a broken coffin at the end of the passage past the shortcut door to the Burial Chamber. You need the Metal Detector, three Octagons, and the PEDRO grave puzzle finished before the Catacomb entrance opens.

Can I skip the Cemetery Grounds statue puzzle? Not for this one. The Catacomb entrance sits behind the panel that opens when you spell PEDRO, so the Octagon hunt and the Gemini Mausoleum trip are mandatory steps toward the Tormented Souls 2 horseman puzzle.

What happens if I rotate a sword the wrong way? Nothing breaks. Panels rotate freely in both directions, so keep spinning until the blade lines up with the clock position in the table. Victory, however, should be left exactly as you found it — touching that panel is the most common way players accidentally break a solved state.