Tormented Souls 2 Church Mirror Puzzle: Candle Pattern & Other Side Solution

Quick Reference: The Church Puzzle at a Glance

The Tormented Souls 2 church mirror puzzle is the gatekeeper for the final stretch of the game. Solve it and the Church's Other Side opens up — the only route to the Undercroft and, eventually, the Bunker elevator. Miss the clue and you'll be standing in a dim chapel holding a lighter with no idea which candles actually matter.

This guide walks through the Tormented Souls 2 church mirror puzzle from prerequisite to payoff: the paintings you need to read, the candle layout community guides have documented, and the small mistakes that keep players looping around the same pews.

For platform and release details, see Tormented Souls 2 on Steam, the game's official store page.

What the Tormented Souls 2 Church Mirror Puzzle Unlocks

The mirror is a large, framed piece mounted on the right side of the main chamber, with writing scratched across the glass and a ring of unlit candles beneath it. Inspecting it confirms what it is: an Other Side mirror, the same kind of transit point you used in the School and the Convent.

Lighting the correct candles wakes it up, and interacting with the glass drops you into the Church (Other Side) — a fenced-off, monster-heavy version of the chapel where the altar area is patrolled by mutants. That detour isn't optional. The Other Side is where the path to the Undercroft begins, and the Undercroft is where the Bunker elevator waits.

The catch is that you can't simply walk up to the mirror. The Church's front steel gates start locked from the far side, so the route loops up through the balcony, through a safe room, and back down behind the gates.

Before You Solve the Tormented Souls 2 Church Mirror Puzzle

Three things need to happen first. None of them are hard, but skipping any one of them leaves you standing in front of dead glass.

Step 1: Open the Church gate

After escaping the School with the Master Key, head to the Commercial District. The dial combination is painted on the pavement in front of the gate: a rose stands in for love (heart), the martial artist stands in for yin-yang, and the Three Wise Men stand in for the star. Set the dials, unlock the gate, and step inside.

Step 2: Repair the Church elevator

The elevator in the corner of the main chamber is dead until you reconnect the generator beside it. The parts you need:

Attach the hose to the pipes, run the coil between the ends, then tighten it with the pliers. A monster spawns in the Wake Room on your way back out — running past it is cheaper than fighting.

Step 3: Walk the balcony route to the mirror

Ride the elevator up and follow the balcony. The rear corner holds shotgun ammo and painkillers, though grabbing them triggers a small ambush. On the far side, a door leads into the Sacristy; keep going down the corridor and the stairs to reach the Administrative Office, which serves as the Church's save room. Save, exit through the door at the far end, and you'll land in the main chamber on the wrong side of those steel gates. Open both, then cross to the right-hand wall.

How to Solve the Tormented Souls 2 Church Mirror Puzzle

With the gates open, the mirror is a short walk away. The writing on the glass points you back to the numbered Christ paintings hung around the Church — Stations of the Cross scenes showing Jesus carrying the cross.

The logic is straightforward once you see it: the candles tied to scenes where Christ is not being weighed down by the cross are the ones you light. Scenes where the cross is pressing down on him stay dark. Note the numbers on the paintings before you climb the balcony; reading them from memory while standing at the mirror is how most players lose ten minutes.

PowerPyx documents the candle ring as a sequence rather than a grid. In their order:

1. Light the candle at the very top on the right side.
2. Light every remaining candle on the right side.
3. Light the bottom-left candle.
4. Light the left-side candle immediately above it.
5. Light the top-left candle.
6. Light the left-side candle two positions below the top-left.

A caveat worth flagging: the published shorthand for this puzzle is inconsistent. Some guides note that the burdened scenes are the ones left unlit, while others phrase it the opposite way around. If the mirror stays inert after your first attempt, light the inverse set — the paintings in the room are the tiebreaker, not the sequence above. That single flip has unstuck plenty of players.

Then:

1. Equip the Lighter.
2. Light only the candles matching your reading of the paintings.
3. Watch the glass — the reflection shifts when the pattern is correct.
4. Interact with the mirror to cross into the Church (Other Side).

If the Tormented Souls 2 church mirror puzzle still refuses to trigger, back out and re-inspect every painting. One missed number usually means two candles in the wrong state.

After the Mirror: Other Side, Undercroft, and the Eye Door

The Church (Other Side) is barricaded into narrow lanes, and three mutants roam the main floor. Clear them, grab the First Aid Kit on the platform above the altar, then take the descending path on the left side, just beside the left staircase.

That door puts you in the Undercroft (Other Side). One more mutant stands between you and the corridor's end, where a second Other Side mirror sends you back to the Undercroft in the real world.

From there, the path runs into a dark room with a lit candelabra below the stairs and a statue nearby. Two things matter here:

• Extinguish the candles around the eye door. Community reports describe doing this on the Other Side before returning to the normal world; other walkthroughs point to the candelabra in the dark room. Do both and you won't have to guess.
• Stand in front of the eye, switch off every light source — the lighter and the detachable battery included — and hold still in complete darkness for a few seconds. The eye glows, the door opens, and the panel beyond it takes you down to the Bunker, the game's final zone.

Common Mistakes That Keep Players Stuck

• Forgetting the detachable battery. The lighter is the obvious light source, but the battery-powered lamp counts too. The eye door will not react if either is on.
• Leaving candles burning. If the eye door won't open, head back and put out the candles around it before trying again.
• Skipping the save room. The Administrative Office is the only checkpoint in this section, and the Other Side fight comes right after the mirror.
• Missing the good ending window. If you want the better ending, grab the Duct Tape from the Convent before committing to the Church. Once you push through this section, Miguel's fate is sealed, per Into Indie Games' Church walkthrough.
• Looking for a map. There isn't one. The Church is compact — the mirror, elevator, Wake Room, and Sacristy are all within a short walk of the main chamber.

NoobFeed's breakdown of every Church puzzle is a useful cross-check if a candle still looks wrong.

FAQ

How do you solve the Tormented Souls 2 church mirror puzzle? Read the numbered Christ paintings around the chapel, then light the candles at the mirror that match the scenes where Christ isn't weighed down by the cross. Use the Lighter, then interact with the glass to cross into the Church (Other Side).

Do you need the Lighter for this puzzle? Yes. The Tormented Souls 2 church mirror puzzle cannot be completed without it, and you pick it up earlier in the Convent by using pliers on the cage around a corpse in the lower Bell Tower.

Can you skip the Tormented Souls 2 church mirror puzzle? No. The mirror is the only way into the Church (Other Side), and the Other Side is the only route to the Undercroft and the Bunker elevator. Every run goes through it.

What waits on the other side of the Church mirror? A fenced-in version of the chapel with three mutants on the main floor, a First Aid Kit above the altar, and a descent on the left side that leads to the Undercroft (Other Side) and a second mirror back to reality.