Tormented Souls 2 Metacritic Breakdown: Critic Scores, User Ratings, and Steam Buzz

Tormented Souls 2 Metacritic Score at a Glance

Nearly a year after launch, the Tormented Souls 2 Metacritic page tells a more interesting story than a single number does. Dual Effect's survival horror sequel shipped for PC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, and Nintendo Switch 2 with a deliberately old-school heart — fixed cameras, tank controls, inventory pressure — and the Tormented Souls 2 Metacritic split between professional critics and players is the fastest way to see whether that pitch landed. Here's what the numbers looked like at the snapshot below, plus what the reviews behind them actually argue.

Snapshot note: every figure in this section comes from Metacritic's Tormented Souls 2 page, captured on October 20, 2026. Scores move as new reviews arrive, so treat these as a dated reading, not a permanent verdict.

That 78 also appears on the game's Steam listing, which carries a Metacritic badge linking out to the critic reviews. So the headline number isn't hiding anywhere: it's a solid "generally favorable" result for a mid-budget indie sequel that never pretends to be a AAA production.

What the Critics Actually Said

Aggregate scores flatten nuance, so it helps to look at the individual reviews that built the 78. Metacritic's page lists the following scored reviews, each dated:

The positive end of that spread focuses on refinement. Combo Infinito argued that the sequel polishes its predecessor's formula without losing the tension, praising smoother controls, more flexible exploration, and puzzles that balance logic with atmosphere — while noting the visuals stay modest and the lighting and sound do the heavy lifting.

IGN Spain went further, calling the sequel a meaningful step past the first Tormented Souls, with ambitious world design, strong characters, and a deep puzzle suite spread across multiple locations. GamingBolt's take centered on atmosphere and classic mechanics, and GameMAG highlighted usability improvements and clearer puzzle hints while flagging combat balance as the weak spot.

The cooler reviews aren't outliers, just less forgiving. SpazioGames described a confident homage that never aims to reinvent the genre and still carries some of the original's flaws. Player 2 was blunter: if you want fixed-camera horror and can tolerate punitive controls, it's your game — otherwise the nostalgia curdles into frustration.

Player Ratings vs. Steam Reviews

Metacritic's user score and Steam's review percentage measure different rooms of the same house, so don't treat them as the same stat. On Metacritic, ordinary users had pushed the Tormented Souls 2 Metacritic user score to 7.8 from 133 ratings as of October 20, 2026 — a "generally favorable" reading that tracks closely with the critic average.

Steam tells a warmer story, with a narrower scope. As of the same October 20, 2026 capture of the game's official Steam store page, the storefront recorded 88% positive from 1,729 Steam purchaser reviews ("Very Positive"), plus 82% positive across the 52 reviews posted in the prior 30 days.

Why the gap? Steam reviews come only from people who bought the game on PC, while Metacritic ratings accept anyone with an account. Both snapshots still land in the same neighborhood: most people who finished the game liked it, and a stubborn minority bounced off it hard.

Community Reports: Where Players Split

Creator commentary fills in the texture that scores can't. In a review video framed as "almost amazing," one player reported a first playthrough of roughly 14 hours with a guide in hand, and described the sequel as bigger but looser than the original — the convent and the school singled out as the best-designed areas, the cemetery as the weakest stretch.

The recurring complaint is puzzle friction. The same creator described a puzzle that only worked after changing a movement option in the pause menu, and speculated it might be a bug rather than intent. That's player experience, not a documented design decision — but it explains why "trial and error" shows up in so many mixed reviews.

On the positive side, community reports consistently praise:

• Quality-of-life upgrades: a quick-select system so you're not reopening the inventory to grab a lighter mid-fight.
• Combat variety: makeshift weapons like the nailer and chainsaw, plus enemies you can shove off by mashing a button instead of losing a fixed chunk of health.
• Identity: the convent, mall, cemetery, and school settings read as their own thing rather than a Resident Evil riff.

The official Steam page confirms the structural side of that: reality-shifting between the real world and the "other side," item combining for puzzles, and a choice between classic fixed-camera tank controls and an assisted mode.

How to Use These Scores Before You Buy

A 78 metascore is a useful filter, not a purchase decision. If you're on the fence, these are the practical levers the sources actually support:

1. Try the demo first. As of the October 20, 2026 Steam page capture, a playable Tormented Souls 2 demo was listed on the store. Puzzle friction is the main divider in reviews, and a demo is the cheapest way to test your patience.
2. Pick your control scheme deliberately. The game supports both fixed-camera tank controls and an assisted mode, so the "punitive controls" complaint in some reviews is partly a settings question.
3. Play with a controller. The developers recommend one, and the Steam page notes Steam Deck Verified status as of that same snapshot.
4. Check the patch state. Steam's news feed listed public beta patch 1.5.0.26 on October 9, 2026, covering gameplay fixes, improved controls, visual enhancements, and stability work — relevant if you're worried about the puzzle bugs players reported at launch.

The safest starting point is the official Tormented Souls 2 Steam store page, where reviews, demo availability, and patch notes all live in one place. For the full review spread, the Tormented Souls 2 Metacritic page is the primary record.

FAQ

Is the Tormented Souls 2 Metacritic score good? Yes, by Metacritic's own bands. As of October 20, 2026, the Tormented Souls 2 Metacritic page recorded a Metascore of 78 from 21 critic reviews and a user score of 7.8 from 133 ratings — both labeled "Generally Favorable."

Do critics and players actually agree on Tormented Souls 2? Broadly, yes. Criticism clusters around puzzle logic and controls rather than the core loop. Steam's 88% positive from 1,729 purchasers (as of October 20, 2026) is the friendliest reading of the three; Metacritic's 7.8 user score is the most moderate.

Why do some reviews mention bad puzzles? Community reports describe puzzles that fail silently or require odd workarounds, including one that reportedly needed a movement-option change in the settings menu. Metacritic's mixed reviews echo that trial-and-error complaint. Developer patches have since targeted gameplay fixes and controls.

Where should I check the live numbers? Go straight to the Metacritic game page and the game's Steam store page. Every figure here is a dated snapshot from October 20, 2026, and review counts on both sites keep climbing.